QUALCOMM Expresses Disappointment Over Jury Verdict

Feb. 13, 2007
SAN DIEGO, CA—QUALCOMM, Inc., a developer of code-division multiple access (CDMA) and other advanced wireless technologies, stated that a federal jury in San Diego has found that Broadcom did not infringe two of QUALCOMM's patents related to video ...

SAN DIEGO, CA—QUALCOMM, Inc., a developer of code-division multiple access (CDMA) and other advanced wireless technologies, stated that a federal jury in San Diego has found that Broadcom did not infringe two of QUALCOMM's patents related to video encoding, although the jury ruled that the patents are valid. The two patents are US Patents Nos. 5,452,104 and 5,576,767 relating to techniques for compressing digital video signals for more efficient storage or transmission which QUALCOMM had alleged were infringed by Broadcom's integrated circuits (ICs) for use in high-definition set-top cable- and satellite-television boxes and certain other high-definition video equipment. QUALCOMM does not currently have a licensing program for this product area. Consequently, the jury's verdict will have no impact on QUALCOMM's existing licensing business.

In addition, the jury provided an adverse advisory verdict on two issues that, by law, must ultimately be decided by the trial judge: whether QUALCOMM had waived its rights to enforce either of these patents against Broadcom by virtue of QUALCOMM's participation in a video standards-setting body, and whether QUALCOMM had engaged in conduct before the Patent Office during the application process that would render either of the patents unenforceable. The judge has not yet set a schedule for his decision regarding these issues.

"We appreciate the difficult task that the jury faced in trying to understand the complex technical issues in the case, and are pleased that they found that our patents are valid," comments Lou Lupin, QUALCOMM's executive vice president and general counsel. "We disagree with the remainder of the jury's findings and are quite disappointed with the advisory votes. We have prosecuted thousands of patent applications in the US Patent Office over the past two decades and have worked very hard to be candid and forthright in all of our dealings there. Similarly, we have carefully followed the rules and IPR policies of the many standard setting organizations in which we participate. Standards are very important to our business, and the integrity of standard setting organizations matters to us very much. We believe a careful examination of the facts does not support either of the jury's advisory verdicts."

This case is only the first of QUALCOMM's four patent-infringement lawsuits against Broadcom that are to be tried before the end of this summer. QUALCOMM also has a case pending against Broadcom for misappropriating QUALCOMM's trade secrets.

For further information, see QUALCOMM's website at www.qualcomm.com

Sponsored Recommendations

MMIC Medium-Power Amplifier Covers 6 to 12 GHz

Nov. 11, 2024
Mini-Circuits is a global leader in the design and manufacturing of RF, IF, and microwave components from DC to 86GHz.

RF Amplifier and Filter Testing with Mini-Circuits Power Sensors

Nov. 11, 2024
RF power sensors are essential for accurately measuring RF components like filters and amplifiers, focusing on parameters such as insertion loss and gain. Employing instruments...

High-Frequency Modules to 110 GHz

Nov. 11, 2024
Mini-Circuits’ wide selection of high-frequency modules are designed, assembled and tested in-house by the best talent in the industry at our Deer Park Technology Center. The ...

Defense Technology: From Sea to Space

Oct. 31, 2024
Learn about these advancements in defense technology, including smart sensors, hypersonic weapons, and high-power microwave systems.