Image

What Would Tesla Do?

March 2, 2015
How can you design or repair anything without being able to measure key parameters?

I am continually amazed at how the pioneers of electronics, and microwaves in particular, did their research and development with little or no test equipment.  How can you design or repair anything without being able to measure key parameters?  Yet with little more than basic meters, the early inventors were able to do a great deal.  Hertz, Tesla, Marconi, and others actually got by without significant measurements.  We can’t do that today.

D’Arsonval meters were available even in the 19th century, but these mostly measured DC and later AC with rectification. RF measurements were particularly difficult if not impossible. Frequency and wavelength measurements were made with so-called wavemeters, just a tunable resonant circuit or cavity. Slotted coax and waveguide lines provided another way to measure wavelength. Luckily, someone figured out you could use a diode for mixing and downconversion, thereby permitting measurements at lower frequencies.

Despite the lack of real test gear, we were able to get radar, VHF/UHF/microwave radios, and satellites.  I have to imagine that there was lots of seat-of-the-pants SWAG-ing going on, but it got done somehow.  The early pioneers really had to invent their own measurement solutions along with their main objectives. Or they did not measure at all.

Just out of curiosity, I looked back at some of my early college radio and radar texts by Terman and others to see what they had to say about RF measurements. Not much, as I found out.  Even the widely acclaimed World War II era MIT Radiation Lab series of books had little to say about measurements.  Remember these books?  There were 28 of them and only two that I remember covered measurement of any kind. An early employer of mine had a full set of these books that I would regularly reference. I wish I had a set even today. Lots of good, original theory and practice in there.

We are lucky today to have a wide range of great microwave test gear from multiple vendors. Signal generators, spectrum analyzers, power meters, noise meters, vector network analyzers, vector signal analyzers, and lots of other special instruments. We can even measure weird stuff like PIM. There is very little we cannot measure reliably. Given the massive complexity of modern RF systems and products, we should be thankful we have some measurement tools. Prices are very high, but undoubtedly justified in most cases.

For example, how does one test and evaluate a WiGig 802.11ad product? It uses OFDM on 60 GHz with MIMO and beam steering. 5G cellular will be just as difficult or worse. Good luck with that. Yet, there are a few companies that can provide instruments that will make those measurements. Still, I keep thinking about those researchers working beyond 100 GHz. What do they use? And how does one measure a THz signal, much less generate it?

Anyway, rest assured that there are a few test companies working on the leading edge of microwave, millimeter wave, and THz wave products. It may be a while before we see some of them, but eventually we will be able to use them—if we can afford them.

While our pioneers were able to get by with few if any measurements, we cannot do that today. We cannot design or otherwise deal with the complexity, government regulations, certification requirements, and other factors without precise and rigorous tests. Thank your test equipment vendors who allow you to do your work.

About the Author

Lou Frenzel | Technical Contributing Editor

Lou Frenzel is the Communications Technology Editor for Electronic Design Magazine where he writes articles, columns, blogs, technology reports, and online material on the wireless, communications and networking sectors. Lou has been with the magazine since 2005 and is also editor for Mobile Dev & Design online magazine.

Formerly, Lou was professor and department head at Austin Community College where he taught electronics for 5 years and occasionally teaches an Adjunct Professor. Lou has 25+ years experience in the electronics industry. He held VP positions at Heathkit and McGraw Hill. He holds a bachelor’s degree from the University of Houston and a master’s degree from the University of Maryland. He is author of 20 books on computer and electronic subjects.

Lou Frenzel was born in Galveston, Texas and currently lives with his wife Joan in Austin, Texas. He is a long-time amateur radio operator (W5LEF).

Sponsored Recommendations

Wideband Peak & Average Power Sensor with 80 Msps Sample Rate

Aug. 16, 2024
Mini-Circuits’ PWR-18PWHS-RC power sensor operates from 0.05 to 18 GHz at a sample rate of 80 Msps and with an industry-leading minimum measurement range of -40 dBm in peak mode...

Turnkey Solid State Energy Source

Aug. 16, 2024
Featuring 59 dB of gain and output power from 2 to 750W, the RFS-G90G93750X+ is a robust, turnkey RF energy source for ISM applications in the 915 MHz band. This design incorporates...

90 GHz Coax. Adapters for Your High-Frequency Connections

Aug. 16, 2024
Mini-Circuits’ expanded line of coaxial adapters now includes the 10x-135x series of 1.0 mm to 1.35 mm models with all combinations of connector genders. Ultra-wideband performance...

Ultra-Low Phase Noise MMIC Amplifier, 6 to 18 GHz

July 12, 2024
Mini-Circuits’ LVA-6183PN+ is a wideband, ultra-low phase noise MMIC amplifier perfect for use with low noise signal sources and in sensitive transceiver chains. This model operates...