CONNECT WITH MWRF
  • Facebook
  • Facebook
Subscribe

  
Reprints   Printer-Friendly    Email this Article    RSS        Font Size     What's This?


[Editorial]
Tubes Still Have Traction

Jack Browne  |  ED Online ID #22395 |  February 18, 2010

This week’s announcement by HEICO Corporation, that it had added noted TWTA and microwave power module (MPM) supplier dB Control to its Electronic Technologies Group, was something of a vote of confidence in that aging but trusted technology, vacuum electronics. Such devices as traveling-wave tubes (TWTs), klystrons, and magnetrons were core components in the earliest of microwave military systems and continue to be widely used in military and aerospace applications to this day.

Although users of vacuum-electronic devices in commercial broadcast, industrial, and even military applications have long read reports about the demise of this technology, it continues to thrive, even with growing claims of higher power levels from exotic semiconductor processes, such as silicon carbide (SiC) and gallium nitride (GaN) transistors. But what is the truth of how much power is really available from each technology at different frequencies, and which ratings refer to continuous-wave (CW) and which to pulsed power levels (and at what duty cycles)? For those interested, some of the answers will appear in an exclusive report in a special military electronics supplement in the March issue of Microwaves & RF.








Reprints   Printer-Friendly    Email this Article    RSS        Font Size     What's This?




Reader Comments

This is a coming attractions advertisement, not an article

JIm the Engineer -February 22, 2010   (Article Rating: )

Yes we all know tubes are still viable. Now how about giving us some usefull information rather than just plugging next months 'issue'?

Bob the Builder -February 21, 2010   (Article Rating: )

TUBES still have their place in electronic systems.

Anonymous -February 19, 2010   (Article Rating: )

Very interesting! I worked on solid-state amplifiers at Collins Radio Company in the 1960s when designing a solid state amplifier that would work at 300 MHz was a major challenge. We thought that tubes would always be required for UHF and high power applications. But technology moves on! I collect vacuum tubes and am glad to hear that they are still useful. I cannot understand the audiophiles that prefer vacuum tubes to solid state amplifiers, though. In that context, I regard vacuum tubes as I do steam locomotives: I love to see them in operation, but I am glad we do not depend on them for everyday applications!

Jim Cook -February 19, 2010   (Article Rating: )

Interesting points that tube amplfiers are still viable. On reason is they are often more efficient than solid state amplifiers.

Duane J. Matthiesen -February 18, 2010   (Article Rating: )

Next Time , please add more details about applications , solutions , technical issues , advantages and technology high lights

Arike123 -February 18, 2010   (Article Rating: )

I think Tube base technology still has an advanteage for broadband performance, Efficiency and Psat/$cost at this moment. Solid-state and tube will have be coextist. -toshi

Toshi Nakamura -February 18, 2010   (Article Rating: )